por v. para 2

JanuszC1Kwiziq community member

por v. para 2

Thank you Silvia,

You write that  "for" in 

"she has made many sacrifices for her children"

implies a cause / an originating reason.

If so, why  "for" in 

"she has made many books for her children"

does not imply a cause?

 

Also, is the following ungrammatical:

"Ha hecho muchos sacrificios para sus hijos."

Asked 4 months ago
SilviaKwiziq team memberCorrect answer

Hola Janusz,

In your example, the use of both prepositions por or para is grammatically correct, but it depends on the nuance you want to convey.

Por indicates origin or cause, while para indicates purpose or the recipient of an action. In the case of your sentence with the sacrifices, if they are for a cause, we will use por, and if it's for a purpose or to indicate the recipient of an action, para.

I hope this clarifies your doubt.

Silvia

Janusz asked:View original

por v. para 2

Thank you Silvia,

You write that  "for" in 

"she has made many sacrifices for her children"

implies a cause / an originating reason.

If so, why  "for" in 

"she has made many books for her children"

does not imply a cause?

 

Also, is the following ungrammatical:

"Ha hecho muchos sacrificios para sus hijos."

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Clever stuff happening!