I don't understand this sentence structure

Doug R.A1Kwiziq community member

I don't understand this sentence structure

¡No puedo creer lo que ven mis ojos!  Why is it necessary to include the verb 'ven' in the sentence? It makes perfect sense without it?  "I can't believe my eyes."
Asked 3 weeks ago
SilviaKwiziq Native Spanish TeacherCorrect answer

Hola Doug R. and Clara M.

That’s a great question and your intuition is right that I can’t believe my eyes works perfectly in English. Spanish, however, often expresses this idea a bit differently.

In No puedo creer lo que ven mis ojos, the verb ver is necessary because lo que introduces a relative clause that means what my eyes are seeing.

So the structure is:

No puedo creer + lo que + verb + subject

Literally:

I can’t believe what my eyes see / are seeing.

If we said No puedo creer mis ojos, it would sound incomplete or unnatural in Spanish, because creer normally needs a clause or idea to believe, not just a body part on its own.

So while English uses a fixed idiom (my eyes), Spanish prefers to make the idea explicit by saying what the eyes are seeing.

Both languages express the same meaning but they just package it differently.

Hope that helps clarify it!

Saludos

Silvia

Clara M.C1Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

Hi Doug,

I think if it said:

 "No puedo creer mis ojos"= I can't believe my eyes, this would be as if my eyes were actually telling me something, my eyes were speaking. 

Since my eyes can't in fact speak then maybe it's better to say: 

"No puedo creer lo que ven mis ojos":

Literal translation: 

 I can't believe what (lo que/that which) my eyes (ven=they see) see/are seeing.

It's just my opinión though Doug.

Clara M.C1Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

Thank you Silvia 🤩

Doug R. asked:

I don't understand this sentence structure

¡No puedo creer lo que ven mis ojos!  Why is it necessary to include the verb 'ven' in the sentence? It makes perfect sense without it?  "I can't believe my eyes."

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it

Find your Spanish level
Getting that for you now...