Fue en Cádiz

John O.C1 Kwiziq Q&A super contributor

Fue en Cádiz

Hola Inma,

Is the use of "ser" in this sentence to indicate where the carnival took place? It caught me out because "It was in Cádiz" sounded as if it was talking about the location (estar), rather than being about where the event happened. If so, I remembered that there is a specific lesson about this in Level A1 "Using Ser not Estar when talking about when / where something takes place." I'm not sure if my thinking is right.

If it is, would it be a good idea to include this lesson in the "All related grammar and vocal list?"

Saludos

John 

Asked 4 years ago
InmaNative Spanish expert teacher in KwiziqCorrect answer

It is indeed a A1 lesson. Here it is. 

Having published this Writing Challenge, I am not sure we can include that link now. I will ask and see if we can include it post-publishing. We tend to include lessons of the level we are aiming the exercise for, but I agree this one would be a good one as it is often a bit confusing because of the "something taking place" and "location" concept. 

Gracias por la sugerencia.

Saludos,

Inma

John O. asked:

Fue en Cádiz

Hola Inma,

Is the use of "ser" in this sentence to indicate where the carnival took place? It caught me out because "It was in Cádiz" sounded as if it was talking about the location (estar), rather than being about where the event happened. If so, I remembered that there is a specific lesson about this in Level A1 "Using Ser not Estar when talking about when / where something takes place." I'm not sure if my thinking is right.

If it is, would it be a good idea to include this lesson in the "All related grammar and vocal list?"

Saludos

John 

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Let me take a look at that...