Cuando + presente de Subjuntivo to express future intentions

Cuando + presente de Subjuntivo to express future intentions

How would you say "When she opens her presents at Christmas she often gets perfume"? The answer given is: "Cuando ella abre sus regalos en navidad a menudo tiene perfume." The present subjunctive for abrir (3rd person) is abra, no?
Asked 1 year ago
SilviaKwiziq language super star
Dear William, thank you for your question. This lesson talks about using "cuando" with Presente de Subjuntivo to express future intentions. However, you can also use Presente de Indicativo to talk about facts. In your example, the fact of opening presents doesn't refer to the future but as a general event instead. It means "everytime that she opens her presents in Christmas she usually gets a perfum." Therefore we can't use Presente de Subjuntivo here, because it doesn't refer to the future. I hope it makes sense! Muchas gracias, Silvia.
NevB1
Then surely either the lesson should mention this difference, or the question shouldn't link to this lesson?
SilviaKwiziq language super star
Hola Nev! This difference between the indicative and the subjunctive is already mentioned in the lesson. Thanks for your contribution! Silvia

Cuando + presente de Subjuntivo to express future intentions

How would you say "When she opens her presents at Christmas she often gets perfume"? The answer given is: "Cuando ella abre sus regalos en navidad a menudo tiene perfume." The present subjunctive for abrir (3rd person) is abra, no?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level >>
Ask a question
Let me take a look at that...