Subjunctive - tener

Brendan w.B2Kwiziq community member

Subjunctive - tener

The examples make sense of using, ex: tuviera, because the subject “had” something in the past. However, I’m confused by the test question because I don’t see a reference to the past. The sentence is “I hope i have a son by the time im 33.” I understand Ojalá triggers the subjunctive but I don’t see the connection to the last and therefore don’t understand why “tuviera” was the correct answer. I only selected it because it was the only subjunctive response. 

Asked 2 weeks ago
SilviaKwiziq Native Spanish TeacherCorrect answer

Hola Brendan w.

This is a great observation and your confusion makes total sense here.

The key point is that the imperfect subjunctive (tuviera/tuviese) is not only used for past time. It’s also used after certain expressions like ojalá when referring to wishes that are unlikely, hypothetical or not yet real.

So in your sentence:

¡Ojalá tuviera un hijo a los 33!

this doesn’t mean “I hoped I had a son (in the past)”, but rather something like:

'I wish I had / I could have a son by the time I’m 33.'

Even though there’s a reference to the future (a los 33), the speaker is expressing a hypothetical or uncertain wish, which is why Spanish uses the imperfect subjunctive.

If the wish felt more realistic or immediate, you might see the present subjunctive instead:

"Ojalá tenga un hijo a los 33" (I hope to have a son by 33 — more neutral/possible)

So the contrast isn’t really about past vs present, but about degree of reality/likelihood.

Hope that helps clarify it!

Saludos

Silvia

Brendan w. asked:

Subjunctive - tener

The examples make sense of using, ex: tuviera, because the subject “had” something in the past. However, I’m confused by the test question because I don’t see a reference to the past. The sentence is “I hope i have a son by the time im 33.” I understand Ojalá triggers the subjunctive but I don’t see the connection to the last and therefore don’t understand why “tuviera” was the correct answer. I only selected it because it was the only subjunctive response. 

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it

Find your Spanish level
I'll be right with you...