The examples make sense of using, ex: tuviera, because the subject “had” something in the past. However, I’m confused by the test question because I don’t see a reference to the past. The sentence is “I hope i have a son by the time im 33.” I understand Ojalá triggers the subjunctive but I don’t see the connection to the last and therefore don’t understand why “tuviera” was the correct answer. I only selected it because it was the only subjunctive response.
Subjunctive - tener
- « Back to Q&A Forum
- « Previous questionNext question »
Subjunctive - tener
Hola Brendan w.
This is a great observation and your confusion makes total sense here.
The key point is that the imperfect subjunctive (tuviera/tuviese) is not only used for past time. It’s also used after certain expressions like ojalá when referring to wishes that are unlikely, hypothetical or not yet real.
So in your sentence:
this doesn’t mean “I hoped I had a son (in the past)”, but rather something like:
Even though there’s a reference to the future (a los 33), the speaker is expressing a hypothetical or uncertain wish, which is why Spanish uses the imperfect subjunctive.
If the wish felt more realistic or immediate, you might see the present subjunctive instead:
So the contrast isn’t really about past vs present, but about degree of reality/likelihood.
Hope that helps clarify it!
Saludos
Silvia
Don't have an account yet? Join today
Find your Spanish level for FREE
And get your personalised Study Plan to improve it
Find your Spanish level