how to ask one and not the other

George H.A1Kwiziq community member

how to ask one and not the other

How might a speaker differentiate an inquiry of How is X? from What is X like?  (Context is usually enough, but both questions are common so it'd be nice to know.)

Asked 1 year ago
InmaNative Spanish expert teacher in KwiziqCorrect answer

Hola George

If you are specifically asking about the boss as in "what s/he is like (to work for)" then you need:

¿Cómo es el jefe/la jefa? 

because what you really want to know is what sort of personality / behaviour he/she normally has ( = what they are like)

A possible answer to this could be: 

"La jefa es muy simpática, así que te gustará trabajar con ella."

The boss is very friendly, so you'll enjoy working with her.

"¡El jefe es un ogro! Siempre está exigiendo cosas y tiene muy mal carácter."

The boss is an ogre! He is always demanding things and has a very bad character.

 

 

If you are specifically asking about the boss as in "what the boss is like that day" then you need:

¿Cómo está el jefe/la jefa [hoy]?

because what you want to know his their mood at the moment.

A possible answer could be:

"Pues hoy está regular, un poco gruñón, no sé por qué."

Well, today he is so so, a bit grumpy, I don't know why.

"Pues hoy está de buen humor y nos ha traído donuts a todos para desayunar."

Well, today he's in a very good mood and he brought us all donuts for breakfast.

 

It helps if you think that in "¿Cómo es...? using ser, you want some descriptive essential characteristics (es simpático, es alto, es bueno, es un ogro...); and you think that with ¿Cómo está...? using estar, you want adjectives and phrases that express how this person is feeling ( estar for feelings: está enfadada, está de mal humor, está contento, está preocupada...)

I hope these examples clarify it a bit more.

Saludos

InmaNative Spanish expert teacher in Kwiziq

Hola George

For any general question where you use "how...?" in English we use "¿cómo...?  and if what you need to ask in English is "what something is like.." expecting a "description of something or someone" you still use ¿cómo es...? in Spanish. 

The common mistake by English speakers is to use "qué..." when they want to ask "what is ... like?" because as you have a "what" in your sentence, you may think you need a "qué.." in the Spanish sentence, but that's wrong as you still need a "cómo".

I think that's what you're asking but not sure...

Saludos

George H.A1Kwiziq community member

Ok, understood.  But let's say I have a new job and ask a coworker How is the boss?  Phrased that way, I imagine that I'm more likely to find out what the boss is like that day, not what s/he is like (to work for).  How to specify the latter?  With the extra "to work for"?  Thank you.

George H. asked:

how to ask one and not the other

How might a speaker differentiate an inquiry of How is X? from What is X like?  (Context is usually enough, but both questions are common so it'd be nice to know.)

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Thinking...