can “cuál” ever be substituted in any of these cases or are there different rules for “cual”?

Linda

Kwiziq community member

10 September 2018

3 replies

can “cuál” ever be substituted in any of these cases or are there different rules for “cual”?

This relates to:
Using qué before a noun in indirect questions -

Linda

Kwiziq community member

11 September 2018

11/09/18

Okay, I think the difference is that “cuál” is “which one” and “qué” is simply “which”.  Is that the main difference?

Silvia

Kwiziq language super star

12 September 2018

12/09/18

¡Hola Linda! We understand that using "qué" vs. "cuál" can be confusing for English speakers, and we hope to create a lesson soon about this grammar point.

The general rule says that "qué" is usually translated as "what", while "cuál" is generally translated as "which".

However, this rule cannot always be applied and in some cases this equivalence doesn't work, so let's see how to use both of them when they mean either "what" and/or "which".

The main difference is that "qué" can be followed by a noun or a verb, but "cuál" can only be followed by a verb or the preposition "de".

When the question implies a choice between two or more alternatives and conveys the idea of "selection", you can use the estructure "¿Cuál + verb/preposition?" or "¿Qué + noun?".

For example:

-¿Qué teléfono es más caro? --> Which telephone is more expensive?

-¿Cuál de los tres teléfonos es más caro? --> Which of the three telephones is more expensive?

Also, when asking about preferences, both "qué" and "cuál" can be used. "Qué" is generally used when the objects you are asking about are not on your sight and options are not given to you, and "cuál" is used when you have them in your hands or in front of you, or are specific objects.

For example:

-¿Qué prefieres, la carne o el pescado? --> What do you prefer, meat or fish?

-¿Cuál prefieres, este o ese? --> Which one do you prefer, this one or that one?

I hope that you can understand a bit better now how to use both of them.

Gracias,

Silvia.

Linda

Kwiziq community member

12 September 2018

12/09/18

Thank you!  That makes it much clearer.  

Your answer

Login to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Think you've got all the answers?

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

find your Spanish level »
280questions497answers131,470users
How has your day been?