2 questions about this test

Nicole P.B1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

2 questions about this test

Re Exercise: The weather forecast Spanish writing exercise EL PRONÓSTICO DEL TIEMPO

Page: On the page: https://progress.lawlessspanish.com/my-languages/spanish/exercises/judge/197/456443?response=61108&;page=3

In Milan it is raining

Kwizbot En Milán está lloviendo 

You Está lloviendo en Milán

Why is my reply not OK?


and this one:

In the east, in Bari there's a storm

Kwizbot En el este, en Bari hay tormenta 

You En el este, en Bari hay una tormenta

Questioin: Would it not be acceptable to use "una" here, since it's a manifestation and not a condition like cloudy?

i.e. there's a cloud: hay un nube; it's cloudy: está nublado (I know it strays a bit from the "hay" format, but it's the only example I can think of. )

Thank you.

Nicole

Asked 5 years ago
InmaNative Spanish expert teacher in Kwiziq

Hola Nicole

We can accept the different order for the first sentence as it doesn't change the meaning at all. So that is now also a possible correct answer in the system. "En Milán está lloviendo"= "Está lloviendo en Milán."

For the second sentence, we don't use the articles when we are simply, with no details, saying what the weather is like, in the form of a "forecast". This was our intention with this exercise, so we can only admit "hay tormenta". If we were a bit more specific about the storm and gave a few more details about it then we would use the article, for example: "En Bari, hay una tormenta muy grande, que ...."

But this is not the case.

I hope this helps,

Saludos

Inma

Nicole P.B1Kwiziq Q&A regular contributor

Thank you so much Inma, perfect! You are a super star!

Nicole

Nicole P. asked:

2 questions about this test

Re Exercise: The weather forecast Spanish writing exercise EL PRONÓSTICO DEL TIEMPO

Page: On the page: https://progress.lawlessspanish.com/my-languages/spanish/exercises/judge/197/456443?response=61108&;page=3

In Milan it is raining

Kwizbot En Milán está lloviendo 

You Está lloviendo en Milán

Why is my reply not OK?


and this one:

In the east, in Bari there's a storm

Kwizbot En el este, en Bari hay tormenta 

You En el este, en Bari hay una tormenta

Questioin: Would it not be acceptable to use "una" here, since it's a manifestation and not a condition like cloudy?

i.e. there's a cloud: hay un nube; it's cloudy: está nublado (I know it strays a bit from the "hay" format, but it's the only example I can think of. )

Thank you.

Nicole

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

Ask a question

Find your Spanish level for FREE

Test your Spanish to the CEFR standard

Find your Spanish level
Thinking...